Makes sense. Although, since I have the server up right now with a bad key (possibly), is there a way to reset this?
I've tried rolling back the cogstartup.xml to the one from the image, and deleting (backup) the folders you mentioned, and then before my first test of the configurations I changed the references from Server1 to Server2, as well as a new content store db. I still get the same type of error;
CAM-AAA-0185 CCLConfiguration exception was caught. Error message: 'CAM-CRP-1280 An error occurred while trying to decrypt using the system protection key. Reason: javax.crypto.BadPaddingException: Given final block not properly padded'.
Seems like I should be able to turn off encryption or remove it and then re-add it to create new keys. Or even just simply set new keys.